I tried to watch Nausicaa today but I fell asleep during it. Its loosely like mononoke, but the dialog is so bad. The characters constantly point out everything thats going on, when the viewer is smart enough to figure it out. The main character was pretty cool. The fighting/flying scenes and other things made no sense to me as I periodically woke up trying to watch it.
Kids might be able to sit through it, but not me.
Kids might be able to sit through it, but not me.
posted by:
|
|
Unsubscribed |
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Mon, August 8, 2005 - 2:03 PMwell it was made in the early to mid 1980's....and i have to differ in my opinion. It was his earlier works so one must take that into consideration and once that has been done it is an entertaining watch - especially on agood a nd proper lazy afternoon.
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Mon, August 8, 2005 - 2:17 PMI hope you didn't sit through the dubbed version...
This and totoro were my favorites of his. I hated mononoke. -
-
Unsu...
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Mon, August 8, 2005 - 8:33 PMI havent seen totoro. Whats wrong with mononoke? Its classic I'm sorry to say. Demons & spirits and man! Thats so japanese. I liked spirited away in a different way too.
-
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Mon, August 8, 2005 - 9:00 PMI liked the design of things... Can't say I liked anything else.
-
-
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Mon, August 8, 2005 - 9:16 PMI thought Nausicaa was fascinating. I don't think you can judge it until you really watch it. Sleeping through it and waking up periodically doesn't count!
Personally, I see it as the flipside of Mononoke. Both films have similar themes (and even characters), yet Nausicaa has a relatively happy ending, while Mononoke has a very unresolved, pessimistic conclusion. Its possible that the films are speaking to two totally different generations.
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Tue, August 9, 2005 - 1:23 PMTo be more specific, Mononoke is "like " Naussica, as it is pre-dated by over a decade. It was a movie based on a much more covnvoluted Manga, and much like a AKIRA, it lost more than a bit in transition. You are correct in that is was written for aslightly younger audience, but it has plenty for someone in their twenties or even thirties. My father is even a big fan. Give it a shot when you are more awake, and see Porco Rosso if you get a chance. -
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Tue, August 9, 2005 - 2:28 PMI didn't just mean a younger age group, but a different generation in general. It seems to me that a film made in the early 80s and a film made in the mid-90s are going to have different angles simply because of when they were made, and what was in the air at the time they were made.
Nausicaa (like other films from that era: Star Wars comes to mind) seems strickly good vs. evil, while Mononoke is more confrontational with its characters, such as Lady Eboshi and San, who are hardly as cut and dry as Nausicaa and her female conterpart (the name escapes me). The characters are more complex in Mononoke and so are the answers. At the end of Mononoke there seems to be no clarification on the relationship between the wilderness and culture. San prefers her wolf family to humans and it appears she has developed more of a truce with humans (via Ashitaka) rather than a bond like the one Nausicaa has with the Ohmu.
Personally, I think the movies compliment each other. Everything can be contrasted: the heroines, the villians, the relationships between the different civilizations, even the two large creatures (the God Soldier and the Forest Spirit). I can say one is better than the other. -
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Tue, August 9, 2005 - 2:30 PMI CAN'T say one is better than the other.
-
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Tue, August 9, 2005 - 6:50 PMI just saw porco Rosso and really had a lot of fun watching it..
I have yet to see Nausicca
-
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Fri, September 7, 2007 - 4:42 PMActually, it's the other way around -- Mononoke is like Nausicaa, as Nausicaa is older, but that's being nitpicky. ;)
I was highly disappointed with Nausicaa as well but, then, I read the manga first. If you are a fan of Miyazaki at all, I highly recommend reading the Nausicaa manga from which the anime was adapted. And by "adapted" I mean skinning it down to the bones, inflating the head, and calling it whole. It'd be like taking a 39 episode series and boiling it into a 90-minute film. That's what happened. They left out SO much. -
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Sat, September 8, 2007 - 4:40 PMi *love* nausicaa. it's one of my favs. the message, the "there is no pure good, no pure evil"-theme, like in most ghibli movies, the design... hmm, got to read the manga, though, so it seems ;) -
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Wed, September 12, 2007 - 2:18 PM<i>"there is no pure good, no pure evil"-theme</i>
That's what I love about it, too. I am sure I would of liked the film better had I a) not read the manga first and b) not first seen the butchered "Warriors of Wind" version. O_O;
-
-
-
Re: Nausicaa: not that great
Mon, September 10, 2007 - 10:29 AMNausicaa's older than Mononoke (which is one of my Miyasaki favs). Scripting was pretty off then. But it was classic for it's time.
